top of page
Search

Hectoring Hector

Writer: Devin O'Donnell
Devin O'Donnell
Jan 27, 2022
3 min read

Updated: Jan 28, 2022

When we compare three central characters in the Iliad—Achilles, Paris, and Hector—we find interesting similarities and differences. We've already discussed the fact that Achilles and Paris both avoid battle in errant and opposite ways. We've discussed how these two both differ from Hector in his ability to "move" freely through the barriers of the battle zone and the urban domestic home/city. But what about moral concerns? Who is morally superior?


In Aristotle's definition of virtue (Nichomachean Ethics), we see that virtue is the "mean" or the middle point between two vices at the extremes. Imagine a ditch on either side of a road, and thus, the path of virtue lies in the middle of these two errors. For example, courage is the middle point of cowardice, on one end, and recklessness, on the other. If we use this as a framework for understanding these characters, then Paris and Achilles occupy two extremes of manly virtue, while Hector lies at the middle. We often find Paris too much at home with the women in domesticated city of Troy, not in the battle or in the company of fellow soldiers. For most of the epic, we find Achilles, not with the rest of the Argives but separated from them, waiting at the black ships, bitter and alone. Ajax tells Achilles to put some "kindness in your heart," but he nurses his rage (menis) instead.


Hector, on the other hand, falls into neither of these two errors. While he is yet meek and tender with his bride and baby son (Book 6), he does not shirk his responsibility to fight. He knows that he must fight to save Troy. Hector knows that it would not simply be cowardice to remain with his family; he knows that his great skill as the best warrior in Troy obligates him to fight, as he is the best hope Troy has. Thus, he is neither cold and unfeeling with his family, nor is he too womanish and avoiding danger.


But why do we tend to sympathize more with Hector than with Achilles? According to G. K. Chesterton, it's likely because Hector is the superior man. Though Achilles bests Hector in war, he does best him in virtue. Attend to what Chesterton says,


Achilles had some status as a sort of demigod in pagan times; but he disappears altogether in late times. But Hector grows greater as the ages pass, and it is his name that is the name of a Knight of the Round Table and his sword that legend puts into the hand of Roland, laying about him with the weapon of the defeated Hector in the last ruin and splendour of his own defeat. The name anticipates all the defeats through which our race and religion were to pass; that survival of a hundred defeats that is its triumph. (Chesterton, The Everlasting Man)


With this last line, Chesterton anticipates the soul of Western Civilization was founded not on the manliness of Achilles but on the manliness of Hector. He continues,


A later legend, an afterthought but not an accident, said that stragglers from Troy founded a republic on the Italian shore. It was true in spirit that republican virtue had such a root. A mystery of honour, that was not born of Babylon or the Egyptian pride, there shone like the shield of Hector, defying Asia and Africa; till the light of a new day was loosened, with the rushing of the eagles and the coming of the name; the name that came like a thunderclap when the world woke to Rome.


It's not that we simply prefer the "under dog" of Hector's campaign. It's that Hector possesses the prototype of Christian chivalry, meek in court and fierce in battle.



Agenda for Thursday:

  1. Prayer

  2. Begin new additions to the Catechism

  3. Discuss the differences between Hector, Paris, and Achilles

  4. Create a "memory palace" with Mr. Welch

    1. Put into the mind's storage the rhyming summaries of books 1-12

  5. Read Book XIII in the Iliad

    1. pick up with line 775 in Book 13


Agenda for Friday:

  1. Prayer

  2. New Catechism

  3. Review differences between Hector, Paris, and Achilles

  4. Review Final Exam "main ideas" and talking points from the Final Study Guide

  5. Read up line 130 in Book XIV in the Iliad

    1. Discuss key elements from past books:

      1. Book 11, lines 708-730 – note how Achilles' PHILOS is rekindled at the sight of a fellow Argive soldier wounded / also Patroclus' beginning entry onto the scene

      2. Book 12, lines 4-15 – note the true reason for the failure Greek wall


REVIEW HW:


  1. Be perfect as your Father in heaven is perfect. Pray, that you may not stumble.

  2. Bring Iliad books everyday (We read Homer!)

  3. Read Book XIII in the Iliad, up to line 775

  4. All School Finals Schedule

  5. Study for Final Exam Business

    1. Final Exam Sign-ups will be conducted

    2. Final Study Guide


________________




 
 
 

Comments


bottom of page